How to Onboard More ‘A’ Players

Lee Froschheiser

“All Aboard!” — Don’t you just wish that hiring new employees was that easy?

Unfortunately, it’s such a challenge today that in a recent national survey, over 30 percent of CEOs said up to half of their employees are a poor fit for the job. What’s more, putting the wrong person in the wrong position just to fill the vacancy can have dire consequences to your organization in terms of poor employee morale, low productivity and lost opportunities. The impact to your company’s bottom line can be staggering.

The good news is that companies can drastically improve their workforce quality by adopting a proactive mindset and consistently using the right hiring procedures. Of course every company is always looking for good people, but the employees who are considered “A” players are usually working elsewhere – and happily — so they’re less likely to be seeking greener pastures. So if your company’s recruiting strategy isn’t well developed, you’re basically hiring other companies’ “B” and “C” players. True, an occasional “A” player will walk through your door, but you’re more likely to find that elusive diamond through the establishment of solid, consistent recruitment processes.

A multi-layered, robust, recruiting process must be rooted in proactive versus reactive recruiting. In today’s world, many companies have the risky tendency of waiting until a job opening occurs to initiate an emergency job search — reactive recruiting at its worst! In a rush to fill the open position and lacking constant, solid recruiting procedures, the company is more likely to take a less qualified candidate or, in some cases, whoever shows up first.


Plan Ahead With Good Job Descriptions

Avoid such dire measures by establishing a very structured and systemized selection process well ahead of when your company actually needs it. This begins with writing a job description before the actual recruiting process. A good job description includes: the job’s purpose, a detailed breakdown of responsibilities, to whom the new person will report, ways to measure the person’s effectiveness, the job’s vital factors, how the person will spend their time, their authority within the company, and the required competencies, background and experience. The job description also drives your interviewing process and questions, as well as the employee’s training plan. What’s more, writing a job description before recruiting forces you to think through the position, the competencies of the person you need and becomes the blueprint for the success of the job and that person.


Determine the Interview Game Plan

Once you’ve attracted the top candidates, you need an interview game plan. Considering what’s required and wanted in the new hire, what are you truly looking for in an ideal employee, and how do these attributes relate to what’s needed for the position? Also, if given the opportunity, what competencies would your internal or external customers look for from your employee to serve their needs? Whatever these competencies are, the candidate you choose must have them.

Your interview game plan must also include a robust selection process. This enables you to evaluate the potential hire in different ways. For example, you may need to conduct several interviews, and will want to do background check(s) at the very least.


Focus on Professional Development

After successfully hiring an employee, the next step in the recruitment process is to develop this person via ongoing coaching, training and planning that will enable his or her professional growth. Unfortunately, most companies have no structured on-boarding plan for new personnel. By solely focusing on bringing someone “aboard the bus,” they forget to follow through with important ongoing training and development. If this is happening at your company, you’re significantly reducing your retention odds. And if that new recruit is one of those rare “A” players, the loss is even greater.

The first 90 days of employment are critical to the long-term success of the new employee. Therefore you should develop and implement a 90-day training plan to secure the employee’s place within the organization and facilitate his or her improvement. You can vary this training based upon the new employee’s level of experience with your existing systems. But it’s important to train this new hire on business practices, how your company functions and how these fit into the organization, too.

Key to the success of this 90-day training plan is using a mentoring team consisting of a peer, manager and support person. The mentoring team should meet at least monthly to give feedback to the new hire, ensure he or she has someone they can go to with questions, and enable their success at adhering to the 90-day training plan.


Establish Expectations Now

Also during this time, it’s critical to set clear, result-oriented goals. Why? Because setting these requirements will communicate company expectations and accountability for results, ensure that the new employee understands the company’s priorities, and, most importantly, measure whether he or she is the right person for the job. Once the employee successfully completes the first 90 days, you’ll need a six-months-to-one-year, personal-development plan to facilitate his or her advancement and growth. Focus on consistent improvement and job-performance strengthening.


Incorporate the Current Business Plan

Finally, do you have a well-developed, current business plan? From day one, such a plan helps new employees understand the company’s direction and the role they play in it. Based upon the business plan, your recent hire should also grasp the company’s vital factors — the unique set of critical elements that can either hold a company back or propel it to success. Each employee should be assigned personal vital factors that support the company vital factors — an exercise that creates that crucial strategic alignment within your organization.

Following these fundamental strategies is a sure way to onboard those “A” players and, more importantly, keep them aboard the company bus. With the right team in place, you’ll find it’s easier to retain those good workers, maintain strong company morale and meet your business’ goals.


Written by Lee Froschheiser, president and CEO of Map Consulting (MAP) and co-author of the best-selling book, “Vital Factors, The Secret to Transforming Your Business – And Your Life.” Reprinted with the permission of PR/PR. 

For in-depth articles on talent management, get your FREE subscription to the Drake Business Review magazine. Our global publication focuses on your talent management issues and provides solutions from thought leaders and industry experts around the world.

Drake P3® predicts the behaviour and personality of potential candidates against the traits of your existing top performers—before you make a job offer. To find out how Drake P3® can improve your hiring success,


Six Steps to Maximise Productivity

Drake Editorial Team

Employee talent and efficiency determines the pace and growth of an organisation. Whether you have tens, hundreds, or thousands of staff, they are critical resources that must be carefully hired and managed for optimum productivity. The truth is, it doesn’t matter how many resources you have, if you don’t know how to utilise or maximise them, it will never be enough.

Read More


Drake NZ CLIENT Updates

Drake Editorial Team

An update on our business continuity & response to COVID-19. If you have any questions, please feel free to call our Drake branches directly, or on 0800 840 940 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Read More


Reference checks: how to get accurate data

Neil I. Clark

Getting reference checks on your candidates can sometimes be considered unreliable. What are the key ingredients of an effective reference check? This is an important part of performance management...

Read More